Wire Stories

CommScope Wins Appeal Affirming Injunction and $6 Million in Damages Against Dali Wireless

HICKORY, N.C.--(BUSINESS WIRE)--#CommScope--CommScope, a global leader in network connectivity, secured another significant win in its litigation with Dali Wireless (�Dali�). CommScope received a favorable ruling from the Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit. The ruling affirms a lower court judgment that Dali Wireless (�Dali�) willfully infringed five CommScope patents, maintaining the injunction and $6 million enhanced damages against Dali. The ruling also reversed the judgment on a Dali patent, erasing $6.6 million that was awarded to Dali. Following this appeal ruling, the damages awarded nets-out to approximately $3.5 million in CommScope�s favor.

The Federal Circuit ruling follows a lengthy patent infringement suit that was initiated by CommScope in 2016. CommScope enforced five digital distributed antenna system (DAS) patents against Dali�s tSeries and Matrix products. Dali responded by filing two patent infringement counterclaims. Dali asserted one patent (U.S. Patent No. 9,031,521) against CommScope�s FlexWave Prism and a second patent (U.S. Patent No. 9,531,473) against an early version of CommScope�s ION-E product. Following a jury trial, the United States District Court for the Northern District of Texas issued a judgment addressing each party�s patents. CommScope filed an appeal on the judgment addressing Dali�s two patents. Dali filed an appeal on the judgment addressing CommScope�s patents. The Federal Circuit denied Dali�s appeal, thus securing the judgment that Dali Wireless (�Dali�) willfully infringed five CommScope patents.

�CommScope builds world-class communications networks for large venues around the world,� said Matt Melester, chief technology officer for CommScope�s Venue and Campus Networks. �We are pleased with the Federal Circuit ruling. This ruling locks in our first objective for this appeal which was to preserve CommScope�s complete win on each of its five patents.�

As to Dali�s two patents, CommScope�s appeal was successful as to �521 patent asserted against CommScope�s Flexwave Prism product. The Federal Circuit found no infringement, reversing the judgment of the lower court that CommScope�s Flexwave Prism product infringed the �521 patent.

�This reversal on Dali�s 521 patent eliminates the bulk of damages awarded to Dali,� said Matt Melester. �By this win against Dali�s �521 patent, we achieved our second objective that the damages awarded nets-out in CommScope�s favor.�

As to Dali�s �473 patent, the Patent Office has already ruled that the asserted claims are invalid in a parallel Inter Partes Review proceeding. Dali has filed an appeal of that ruling.

All product names, trademarks and registered trademarks are property of their respective owners.

About CommScope:

CommScope (NASDAQ: COMM) is pushing the boundaries of technology to create the world�s most advanced wired and wireless networks. Our global team of employees, innovators and technologists empower customers to anticipate what�s next and invent what�s possible. Discover more at www.commscope.com.

Follow us on Twitter and LinkedIn and like us on Facebook.

Sign up for our press releases and blog posts.

This press release includes forward-looking statements that are based on information currently available to management, management�s beliefs, as well as on a number of assumptions concerning future events. Forward-looking statements are not a guarantee of performance and are subject to a number of uncertainties and other factors, which could cause the actual results to differ materially from those currently expected. In providing forward-looking statements, the company does not intend, and is not undertaking any obligation or duty, to update these statements as a result of new information, future events or otherwise.

Source: CommScope

Contacts

News Media Contact:
Jocelyn Penque, CommScope

+44 7970 605 305 or [email protected]

Financial Contact:
Michael McCloskey, CommScope

+1-828-431-9874

To Top