Categories: Politics

Trump, Putin and Xi leave Shenzhen with a joint declaration, no new pact

Donald Trump left China on Thursday after sitting down with Xi Jinping and Vladimir Putin in Shenzhen, where the three powers issued a joint declaration on peace after what was marketed as 90-minute talks. The leaders gathered around a very large round table inside a state guesthouse on the city’s outskirts, with Xi in the middle, then spoke briefly to media together.

The summit itself was the headline. The joint declaration on peace promised dialogue on reducing nuclear risks and reforming the United Nations, said the three countries planned to increase supplies of petroleum products, and listed immunity for state officials as being of fundamental importance. Beyond that, it offered minimal substance, and separate accounts differed on the length of the meeting, with one number given as 81 minutes. Xi framed the moment historically: “History tells us that when great powers are at peace, the world is secure; when great powers clash, the world is in chaos.” Trump said, “No peace was ever forged by declining opportunities for engagement and speech together,” and Putin called for constructive co-operation.

Three leaders walked in with three different needs

Trump arrived after losses for his party in November’s midterm elections and used the meeting to show he could still convene Xi and Putin together. “We are really making history,” he said at the villa. Earlier in the day he met Putin and Xi separately. He called Putin his “friend”, said the two leaders have had a “great relationship for many years”, and told Xi he believed that as long as the two were in charge, the US and China would never have a problem.

For Putin, the summit was a return to a global stage after nearly five years of isolation following Russia’s invasion of Ukraine. The declaration’s emphasis on immunity for state officials carried weight because Putin is wanted for war crimes by the International Criminal Court. Putin initially proposed the three-way format as a way to discuss Ukraine without Ukraine at the table, and both Xi and Putin invoked the post-Second World War order in their opening remarks, feeding comparisons to the 1945 Yalta conference.

For Xi, the meeting projected China as a diplomatic power broker at a time when economic problems are dogging him at home and US lawmakers are pressing for tighter controls on Chinese access to advanced technology. US officials said Xi was reluctant at first to host tripartite talks if they could overshadow his APEC summit. Yet the lack of concrete outcomes suited Beijing: Xi could stand shoulder-to-shoulder with Trump without making complicated commitments before a key Communist Party conclave next year where he is expected to seek a fourth term.

Ukraine stayed close, and Kyiv did not

Trump had earlier said Ukraine would not be on the agenda, then changed course and said he expected to raise it. “I think things are happening. I think that (Putin) and I hope the other side would like to see an end to that war,” Trump said as the meeting began. Europe watched warily, with officials fearing what the leaders might discuss behind closed doors about a conflict whose front-line state was absent.

The timing was awkward for the peace language. While Putin spoke publicly about ending bloodshed, Russian strikes were hitting the Ukrainian capital, and Trump’s own pledge to resolve the Ukraine war within 24 hours of taking office is now 667 days overdue. Trump’s separate conflict with Iran, which he once predicted would last six weeks, has proved unpopular at home and has become a factor in his search for a diplomatic off-ramp in the east.

Nuclear pacts, diesel waivers and the AI-chip split

Trump said his main objective was nuclear arms control among the world’s largest nuclear states, and he wants a new nonproliferation pact with Moscow and Beijing. “Once you have the nuclear weapons, it’s very hard to not have them,” he said. “It’s the way life works.” Xi appeared uninterested in joining an agreement with two countries whose stockpiles are many times the size of China’s.

The economics stayed tangled. Trump loosened sanctions on Russian diesel imposed after the invasion of Ukraine, trying to lower costs that spiked during the Iran war, a move that also allowed that conflict to enrich Russia. Trade frictions and rare-earth shipments continue to rub between Washington and Beijing. Trump said he would not press China hard on the case of former Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang and an alleged Chinese intelligence asset because he was wary of “insulting” Beijing. Members of his cabinet are more hawkish and want to cut off China’s access to the most powerful AI chips; Trump sounded opposed to any move that could stifle AI’s advances and said the US opposes “any form of globalist regulation.”

Photo-op or turning point

The trilateral meeting came after Trump’s election-era personal outreach to both leaders, including a summit in Alaska last year that has so far failed to end the Ukraine war. Xi and Putin, who five years ago called themselves partners “without limits”, have met dozens of times, and after yet another session on Wednesday, Chinese state media called the relationship “steadfast as a rock through wind and rain.” Both dictators share a view that the global balance of power is shifting eastward as the West weakens.

Trump left open whether the talks would produce more. “A lot of people weren’t sure would something come out of it. I think something … will come out,” he said beforehand as he met Xi. No new treaty was signed in Shenzhen, and Trump said he was weighing military options to restart an intensive round of bombing in Iran.

Rohan Menon

Rohan Menon covers business, personal finance, markets, startups and economic developments. He breaks down complex financial and business topics into clear, easy-to-understand stories for a general audience.

Recent Posts

Netflix Releases ‘The Altruists’: Julia Garner and Anthony Boyle Star in FTX Collapse Drama

Netflix has launched The Altruists, an eight-part limited drama series starring Anthony Boyle and Julia…

48 minutes ago

Messi bows out with 126th Argentina goal as Nico Paz is told he is the No 10 heir

Lionel Messi ended his international career the way the Estadio Monumental crowd had asked for:…

2 hours ago

Uditi Singh Named Bigg Boss 20 Captain After Forehead Injury in Task

Actor Uditi Singh has taken over as the house captain on Bigg Boss 20 following…

3 hours ago

Padmaja Venugopal quits BJP, calls 2024 switch a mistake; Congress return unresolved

Padmaja Venugopal resigned from the Bharatiya Janata Party on Thursday, November 19, calling her 2024…

4 hours ago

VS Babu, the Kolathur MLA who defeated Stalin, dies after a High Court fight over his health

The most reliable public update on Kolathur MLA V.S. Babu's health came from a hospital…

6 hours ago

NASA’s Voyager 1 crosses one light-day from Earth, 48 years after 1977 launch

NASA's Voyager 1 is now one light-day from Earth. That is roughly 16 billion miles…

7 hours ago