Why Trading Mohammed Shami for Sam Curran Risks Unbalancing LSG

Why Trading Mohammed Shami for Sam Curran Risks Unbalancing LSG

Trading an established Indian fast bowler for an overseas all-rounder is always a gamble on team balance, and Lucknow Super Giants swapping Mohammed Shami for Rajasthan Royals’ Sam Curran tests that strategy to its limit ahead of the IPL 2027 retention deadline. Lucknow Super Giants and Rajasthan Royals have entered advanced talks on a multi-player deal that sends Shami to Rajasthan in exchange for Curran, Cricinfo reported. The proposed exchange also includes Tamil Nadu spinner Manimaran Siddharth moving to Rajasthan as part of the trade package.

The move represents a deliberate shift in how Lucknow structures its main squad. By bringing in Sam Curran, LSG acquire an England all-rounder capable of contributing left-arm pace and middle-order runs, but they expend an overseas slot to fill a role previously anchored by a domestic fast bowler.

LSG Gamble on All-Round Versatility Over Domestic Seam Leadership

Surrendering Shami removes a veteran fast bowler from Lucknow’s squad, shifting their pace department’s stability onto less experienced Indian seamers or forcing them to spend another overseas slot on a specialist bowler. Sportskeeda outlined three key reasons why trading for Curran could backfire on Lucknow, focusing on how hard it is to replace a proven Indian fast bowler in the starting XI without disrupting team balance.

When a team trades away a top-tier Indian pacer, it loses flexibility in selecting four overseas players. Curran brings genuine utility with bat and ball, but taking on his contract means Lucknow must reallocate overseas slots across their middle order and bowling attack. For a franchise preparing its squad ahead of the retention deadline, sacrificing Shami’s experience leaves a hole in the powerplay and death overs that an all-rounder cannot single-handedly fix.

Rajasthan Royals Secure a Experienced Indian Fast Bowler

From the Rajasthan Royals’ perspective, acquiring Shami solves a clear squad requirement by bringing in an experienced Indian pace bowler. Rediff reported that Rajasthan set out to strengthen their squad combination by targeting Shami, willingly offloading Curran to secure an established domestic seam option.

Adding Shami gives Rajasthan immediate authority with the new ball while freeing up an overseas spot in their starting lineup. By sending Curran to Lucknow, Rajasthan can deploy that vacant overseas slot elsewhere—whether in an explosive top-order batsman or a specialist fast bowler—making their overall squad composition far more adaptable across different pitch conditions.

Spin Inclusions and Domestic Squad Adjustments

The proposed deal is not a simple one-for-one player swap. News18 reported that the deal expanded into a multi-player trade, with Lucknow Super Giants agreeing to release Tamil Nadu spinner Manimaran Siddharth alongside Shami to complete the exchange for Curran.

Including Siddharth gives Rajasthan additional domestic spin depth, while Lucknow sheds both a senior pacer and a specialized finger spinner in a single move. Releasing Siddharth alongside Shami forces Lucknow’s management to rebuild their domestic bowling unit almost entirely through the upcoming auction, whereas Rajasthan exits the trade with reinforced Indian bowling options across both pace and spin.

Reporting from

About The Author